Red Wings Thrive Without an Enforcer: Here’s Why

The Detroit Red Wings are making headlines, but this time it’s not just for their performance on the ice. A recent fight between Moritz Seider and Mark Kastelic of the Boston Bruins has reignited discussions about the role of fighting in hockey. This tussle took place on November 29 at TD Garden, where Seider stood his ground against a seasoned enforcer, drawing applause for his courage.
Fighting in the NHL: A Diminishing Trend
Fighting has been on a downward trajectory in the NHL for years. According to HockeyFights.com, there have been just 121 fights in the current season. In stark contrast, the league recorded 297 fights last season. The trend marks a significant decline from the late 1990s and early 2000s, when more than 800 fights annually were common.
An Evolving Game
The Red Wings have engaged in only five fights this season, with Seider’s recent bout being the most notable. Comparatively, they had nine fights during the entire previous season. The current hockey landscape is dominated by speed and skill rather than physicality. Players are no longer just enforcers; they are well-rounded athletes.
The Impact of Fighting
While the NHL has moved toward a skill-focused game, fighting remains a strategic tool. Several players and coaches view it as impactful when used appropriately. Red Wings coach Todd McLellan emphasized the need for policing the game but expressed his disfavor for “staged” fights, which generally do not contribute positively to the overall experience.
- Enforcers like Bob Probert and Joe Kocur once played significant roles, balancing physical play with skill.
- Today’s game demands a different skill set, with players needing to contribute offensively while still being able to defend the team’s interests.
- The perception of fighting has evolved; it is now seen more as a motivator than a regular occurrence.
A Shift in Perspective
The Red Wings’ roster reflects a shift in how teams are built. Seider noted that the team does not require a designated fighter. The organization believes they can hold their own without a pure enforcer, relying on strong, versatile players who can handle physical situations.
Since Seider’s fight, the Wings have displayed improved performance, with a record of 9-2-2. This surge in form raises questions about whether the tussle served to galvanize the team. Defenseman Ben Chiarot commented on the boost in morale that comes from seeing a key player like Seider engage physically.
Upcoming Matchup Against Carolina
The Red Wings are set to face the Carolina Hurricanes for the first time this season. The match is scheduled for Saturday at Lenovo Center in Raleigh, North Carolina. Both teams are currently vying for the top spot in the Eastern Conference, each sporting 47 points. Carolina has struggled recently, remaining winless in three games.
- Teams: Red Wings (22-13-3) vs. Hurricanes (22-11-3)
- Notable Players: Sebastian Aho (32 points), Seth Jarvis (19 goals)
As the Red Wings continue their season, the dynamics of fighting and physical play will be intriguing to watch. While the focus is shifting away from fighting, players like Seider are proving that when done strategically, it can still have an invaluable impact on team spirit and performance.



