St. Susanna’s Parish in Dedham has sparked controversy with its annual nativity scene. This year, the traditional display is missing key figures of Jesus, Mary, and Joseph. In their place, a prominent sign reading “ICE was here” has been installed in a nearly empty manger.
Anti-ICE Nativity Scene at St. Susanna’s
The sign implies that immigration agents have taken the figures away, highlighting issues surrounding immigration enforcement. Below this sign, another reads, “The Holy Family is safe in our Church… If you see ICE please call LUCE at 617-370-5023.”
Context Behind the Display
Father Stephen Josoma, the parish leader, aimed to focus this year’s nativity on the theme of immigration. Conversations with refugee families have significantly influenced this decision. Many families from countries like Honduras, Guatemala, and Afghanistan have expressed fears of deportation.
- Concerns about returning to violence in their home countries.
- Emotional and physical scars borne by these families.
Father Josoma described the nativity display as a reflection of the difficult context surrounding Christmas this year. He believes that current immigration policies can feel brutal and threaten the well-being of those already settled in the United States.
Reactions from the Archdiocese
The Archdiocese of Boston has responded critically to the display. Representatives labeled the scene a “politically divisive display” and called for the restoration of the nativity to its sacred purpose. They emphasized that churchgoers expect genuine opportunities for worship rather than political messages.
Church Norms and Guidelines
The Archdiocese noted that St. Susanna’s did not seek permission for the display and indicated that church norms prohibit the use of sacred objects for non-worship purposes. Additionally, they referred to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ longstanding statements favoring humane treatment of migrants while acknowledging a nation’s right to manage borders.
Historical Context of Activism
This is not the first instance of St. Susanna’s Parish using the nativity scene for social commentary. For over a decade, the church has employed this display as a medium for discussing various political issues such as gun control and climate change.
- In 2018, the nativity featured a baby Jesus in a cage, protesting family separations at the border under the Trump administration.
Community Response
Local leaders have expressed frustration regarding this year’s installment. CJ Doyle, head of the Catholic Action League, criticized the parish, labeling it “sacrilegious” political theater. He accused Father Josoma of exploiting the Christmas narrative to push a leftist agenda.
Despite the backlash, Father Josoma defended the nativity scene. He argues that churches have a moral obligation to address pressing social issues. He believes religious art should challenge viewers to reflect and engage in civil discourse about current realities.
In response to critics, he emphasized the importance of acknowledging facts and realities that affect vulnerable populations. This dialogue, according to him, is necessary for genuine understanding and action.
